The Evaluation Review Committee is a standing committee appointed by the ISACS board of trustees. It consists of school heads that have had extensive experience with accreditation; most will be experienced accreditation team leaders. Members of the Evaluation Review Committee generally serve for at least two 3-year terms.

It is the purpose of the Evaluation Review Committee to review all accreditation program procedures periodically and, more specifically, to review all accreditation reports (visiting team, reaction, and progress reports) on behalf of the board of trustees. The Evaluation Review Committee may accept or modify the recommendation for accreditation submitted by the visiting team, and reports this to the board of trustees. In the case of an adverse recommendation (for accreditation), the school will be notified, and will be given an opportunity to appeal if it chooses, before final action by the board.